Sometimes it's difficult to determine whether the benefits of the electronic age are outweighed by the liabilities, whether we as humans by making things easier have made them worse.
A popular Virginia elementary school principal on the verge of retirement was walking near her home obviously engrossed in the music coming from her earphones and was killed by an SUV whose driver was neither drinking nor speeding, according to an initial investigation. The cause of this tragedy apparently was a disease that seems on the verge of pandemic dimensions in the world today -- a lack of awareness of one's surroundings brought on by electronic distraction.
This virus seems to impact us all, often in the most personal way. My kid brother, a brilliant lawyer, was on his way home after a late-afternoon gym session when his car was struck by a pickup at a high rate of speed. He died instantly, leaving his family and friends bereft and his profession worse off. Who was at fault is still being determined. But mark this down as a cautionary tale. Both my brother and the driver of the other vehicle were talking on their phones when the accident occurred. My brother was belted in and all the airbags deployed. Nothing saved him.
It is difficult to drive down the street these days without seeing what seems like half the pedestrians in one's vision with heads down, either texting, talking or listening on some modern convenience, completely oblivious to what is going on around them. Most drivers today must be aware of not only the cars and trucks in their surroundings but the foot traffic as well. It is a new dimension that often requires a heightened defensiveness that can't help but break down more often than not.
Only recently I was forced to slam on my brakes and swerve to miss a young man who had begun crossing the street with his cellphone tightly held in one hand, head down, with his thumbs jumping over the keyboard. He was unaware that he had stepped off the curb while the light was against him. Had I been distracted by another vehicle or speeding at the time, I hate to think of the consequences.
What do we do about this? There may not be a solid solution. State after state has passed laws against driving while on a cellphone, some have even banned hands-free use, arguing that it is a distraction. Not enough have made texting illegal, although that seems preposterous given the clear danger.
The problem, of course, is that these laws are generally ignored and extraordinarily difficult to enforce, particularly if the driver was not speeding or otherwise driving recklessly enough to attract the attention of police. Besides, much of the urban traffic control today has been ceded to cameras and other electronic devices because of budget pressures. Police are too busy with other problems and the cameras only check speed and red-light obedience. In addition they are cheap ways of boosting revenue.
How then can we deal with this increasingly difficult problem? How can we prevent what should be utterly preventable with a little common sense that tells us in today's crowded world we have to be aware of what is around us? How can we convince those who walk or jog with their ears full of music that their lack of awareness to the immediate environment makes them more vulnerable to tragedy? There may be no general solution.
Perhaps we can save some lives if we begin educating youngsters, many of whom have these devices at an early age, as part of our mandatory school curriculums. Why not make fines enormously high for violation of the cellphone ban while driving? We certainly have done that for those who refused to obey the seat belt laws. There might even be a way that use of a handheld cellphone while driving could automatically trigger some device that loudly proclaims this person is a hazard -- maybe a light that warns other vehicles to stay away and alerts the police.
Sounds silly doesn't it? But maybe the school principal and my brother would still be alive.
(Dan Thomasson is former editor of Scripps Howard News Service.)